Finding experienced senior hotel executives is challenging. But what if some of the best candidates are being lost not because of the competition, but because of the recruitment process itself?
Luxury hotels invest heavily in their properties, guest experience, facilities and brand reputation. Yet when it comes to recruiting senior leadership talent, the candidate experience does not always receive the same attention.
A General Manager, Director of Finance, Director of Sales and Marketing or Director of Operations is unlikely to make a career move lightly.
These are experienced professionals with established careers, responsibilities and expectations. They are not simply looking for another job. They are considering whether an opportunity represents a worthwhile next step.
And increasingly, how a hotel manages its recruitment process can influence that decision.
So, could your recruitment process be costing you the very candidates you want to attract?
1. The recruitment process takes too long
One of the biggest frustrations for senior candidates is a recruitment process with no clear direction.
An initial conversation takes place, followed by an interview, then another meeting, perhaps with a different decision-maker. Weeks pass without meaningful feedback.
Meanwhile, the candidate may be considering another opportunity or simply losing interest.
Of course, senior appointments require careful consideration. Owners, operators and HR teams need to be confident in their decisions.
However, there is a difference between a thorough recruitment process and an unnecessarily slow one.
A clear interview structure, agreed decision-making responsibilities and timely feedback can make a considerable difference.
The strongest candidates are assessing your organisation just as carefully as you are assessing them.
2. The opportunity is not as attractive as the hotel believes
A beautiful property, a recognised international brand and an impressive job title do not automatically make an opportunity compelling.
Senior executives look at the bigger picture.
Who will they report to? What authority will they have? What are the expectations of ownership? Is the property undergoing a repositioning? Will they have the resources and support required to succeed?
Compensation is also important.
Salary, bonuses, accommodation, relocation support and other benefits all influence decisions, particularly when recruiting internationally.
This can be especially relevant for luxury resort properties in destinations such as Sardinia, Sicily and other seasonal locations, where relocation and lifestyle considerations may influence a candidate's willingness to move.
Hotels need to understand how their opportunity compares with the wider market, rather than assuming the reputation of the property will be enough.
3. You are only speaking to candidates who are actively looking
Advertising a vacancy is an important part of recruitment, but it only reaches a proportion of the potential talent market.
Some of the strongest executives are already employed in successful properties. They may not be looking at job boards, responding to LinkedIn advertisements or submitting applications.
However, that does not necessarily mean they would not consider the right opportunity.
Reaching these individuals requires a different approach.
It involves identifying professionals with relevant experience, understanding their career backgrounds and approaching them through discreet, informed conversations.
This is one of the fundamental differences between conventional recruitment and specialist hospitality executive search.
The objective is not simply to find people who want a job. It is to identify people who could make a meaningful difference to your hotel.
4. The job brief is unrealistic
Sometimes the difficulty is not the availability of candidates, but the expectations attached to the position.
A hotel may want an executive with experience across several international brands, a particular destination, a specific operational background and an extensive track record, while offering a package that does not reflect the requirements.
Individually, each expectation may seem reasonable. Collectively, they can make the search extremely difficult.
This is where an honest discussion about the candidate market becomes important.
Which requirements are essential? Where is there flexibility? Could someone from a different luxury brand bring equally relevant experience?
A good recruitment partner should be prepared to challenge a brief constructively, explain the realities of the market and help establish a realistic candidate profile.
5. The personal side of recruitment is overlooked
Senior recruitment is not simply a commercial transaction.
An executive considering a move may need to relocate their family, leave an established team, change countries or take on a significantly different ownership environment.
These decisions require trust, confidentiality and a clear understanding of what the opportunity involves.
Candidates want to know that the person representing the hotel understands the position, the expectations and the realities of the business.
Generic approaches and poorly informed conversations rarely create that confidence.
Personal engagement matters, particularly when approaching experienced professionals who are not actively seeking a move.
A different approach to senior hotel recruitment
For luxury hotels, the recruitment challenge is not always a shortage of experienced people.
Sometimes it is about reaching the right individuals, presenting the opportunity effectively and managing the process in a way that encourages strong candidates to remain engaged.
This is where specialist hospitality recruitment can add real value.
At Antal International – London Marylebone, we specialise in executive search and senior leadership recruitment for luxury and five-star hotels across Italy, Europe, the Middle East and Asia.
Our team combines hospitality industry understanding, including former hotel leadership experience, with international networks and a relationship-led approach to identifying senior talent.
We work closely with clients to understand the property, the position, the commercial objectives and the type of individual who will succeed.
We also recognise that successful recruitment depends on both sides of the relationship. Understanding what motivates a candidate is just as important as understanding what a hotel needs.
Whether you are recruiting a General Manager, Director of Finance, Director of Operations, Director of Food and Beverage or another senior hospitality professional, the approach to the search can make all the difference.
One final question for hotel owners and HR leaders
When was the last time you reviewed your senior recruitment process from the candidate's perspective?
You may be surprised by what you discover.
If you are finding it difficult to attract or secure the right senior talent, perhaps it is time to look beyond the vacancy itself.
Antal International – London Marylebone
Specialist executive search and recruitment for luxury and five-star hospitality.
If you have a challenging senior appointment or would like an informed discussion about the available talent market, we welcome a confidential conversation.