he vacancy is advertised. Applications have arrived. Interviews have taken place. Yet weeks later, the right candidate remains elusive. What is going wrong?
For luxury hotels, recruiting senior leadership talent can be one of the most challenging aspects of running a successful operation.
Whether the position is General Manager, Director of Finance, Director of Food and Beverage, Executive Chef or Director of Sales and Marketing, finding the right individual requires more than identifying someone with the relevant experience.
Across Italy, Europe, the Middle East and Asia, luxury hospitality employers compete for executives who combine operational expertise, commercial understanding, leadership capability and the right cultural fit.
So why do some senior hotel vacancies remain open longer than expected?
And, more importantly, what can hotels do differently?
1. The job description is too restrictive
One of the most common challenges in senior hotel recruitment is an overly specific candidate brief.
A hotel may seek someone who has worked for a particular international brand, managed a property of an exact size, operated in a specific destination and held precisely the same title.
Individually, these requirements may seem reasonable. Collectively, they can significantly narrow the available talent pool.
The strongest candidate may come from a different luxury brand, a larger independent property or an adjacent hospitality environment.
The question should not simply be whether a candidate matches every line of the job description, but whether they can deliver the results the hotel needs.
A specialist hospitality recruitment partner can help distinguish essential experience from preferences that unnecessarily restrict the search.
2. The right candidates are not actively looking
A common misconception is that advertising a senior vacancy will attract the strongest available talent.
In reality, many experienced hotel executives are already employed, performing well and not actively considering a career move.
They may be open to the right opportunity, but they are unlikely to discover it through a job advertisement alone.
This is where hospitality executive search differs from conventional recruitment.
Rather than relying exclusively on applications, a targeted search identifies suitable professionals, approaches them discreetly and explores whether an opportunity aligns with their ambitions.
For luxury hotels recruiting critical leadership positions, accessing this wider talent market can make a significant difference.
3. The opportunity is not compelling enough
Senior hotel executives rarely make career decisions based on salary alone.
They consider the reputation of the property, the ownership structure, reporting relationships, commercial expectations, career progression and the opportunity to make a meaningful impact.
Location also plays an important role.
A senior executive considering a move to a seasonal Mediterranean resort may have very different priorities from someone evaluating a year-round position in Dubai, Singapore or London.
If a hotel cannot clearly communicate why an opportunity is attractive, even highly suitable candidates may decline to engage.
Successful luxury hotel recruitment therefore requires a compelling proposition that goes beyond the job title and compensation package.
4. The recruitment process takes too long
Senior candidates often have demanding schedules, competing priorities and multiple career options.
An unnecessarily lengthy recruitment process can weaken their interest.
Repeated interview stages, delayed feedback, unclear decision-making and changing expectations can create uncertainty.
By the time an offer is made, the preferred candidate may have accepted another opportunity or decided to remain with their current employer.
This does not mean hotels should rush important appointments.
It means establishing a clear recruitment process from the outset, including decision-makers, interview stages, assessment criteria and realistic timelines.
A structured recruitment process demonstrates professionalism and reinforces the candidate's confidence in the opportunity.
5. The hotel is searching for a CV rather than a leader
Two candidates may have similar career histories but very different leadership capabilities.
Both may have worked for recognised luxury brands, managed comparable properties and achieved strong commercial results.
However, one may excel in a structured international hotel group, while the other thrives in an independently owned property undergoing repositioning.
One may be particularly effective at developing teams. Another may bring stronger experience in financial restructuring, pre-openings or commercial transformation.
Understanding these differences requires meaningful assessment of the individual—not simply reviewing their career history.
For senior appointments, the objective should be to identify the person most likely to succeed in the specific hotel environment.
When should a hotel consider specialist executive search?
Not every vacancy requires external recruitment support.
Many hotels have capable internal HR teams and established talent acquisition processes.
However, specialist support can be particularly valuable when:
-
A critical leadership vacancy has remained open despite advertising and direct recruitment efforts.
-
The position requires rare technical, commercial or operational expertise.
-
The hotel needs to reach experienced executives who are not actively applying for jobs.
-
A confidential replacement or sensitive leadership appointment is required.
-
The property is preparing for an opening, repositioning or significant operational change.
-
The hotel needs access to senior hospitality talent across international markets.
In these circumstances, the value of a specialist recruitment partner lies not simply in presenting candidates, but in understanding the market, evaluating realistic options and helping the client make an informed appointment.
A different approach to luxury hotel recruitment
At Antal International – London Marylebone, we specialise in senior hotel recruitment and hospitality executive search for luxury and five-star properties across Italy, Europe, the Middle East and Asia.
Our team brings practical hospitality industry experience, including former hotel leadership and General Manager backgrounds, to the recruitment process.
We understand that appointing a senior executive is not simply about filling a position. It is about finding an individual who can contribute to the hotel's operational performance, commercial success, leadership culture and long-term objectives.
Our relationship-led approach combines targeted research, international talent networks, direct candidate engagement and personal assessment.
We believe that the quality of a shortlist matters far more than the number of CVs presented.
Still searching for the right senior hotel executive?
If your hotel has a senior leadership vacancy that is proving difficult to fill, it may be worth reviewing the recruitment strategy before repeating the same approach.
Sometimes the challenge is the candidate brief. Sometimes it is market availability, compensation, location or the recruitment process itself.
Understanding the underlying issue is the first step towards finding a solution.
At Antal International – London Marylebone, we welcome confidential conversations with hotel owners, General Managers, HR Directors and hospitality groups seeking experienced senior leadership talent.
Whether you are recruiting a General Manager, Director of Finance, Director of Operations, Director of Sales and Marketing or another senior hotel executive, we would be pleased to discuss your requirements.