Why luxury hotels should rethink the brief before beginning their next senior recruitment search.
When a senior hotel executive leaves, the instinct is often to find someone just like them.
The same brand background. Similar properties. The same career trajectory. Ideally, someone who has already held an identical position at a comparable hotel.
On paper, it makes sense. The previous person understood the operation, the owners knew what to expect, and the hotel had a familiar model of success.
But there is a question worth asking before the next search begins:
Are you recruiting to replace the person who left, or to meet the challenges your hotel faces next?
They are not necessarily the same thing.
The danger of recruiting from the past
Luxury hotels operate in changing environments. Ownership priorities evolve, guest expectations shift, commercial pressures change and teams develop.
A hotel that needed a strong operational leader three years ago might now need someone with greater commercial experience. A property that has relied on an established brand structure may be preparing for repositioning. A resort entering a new phase of investment may require a different combination of financial discipline, people leadership and strategic thinking.
Yet recruitment briefs can be built around the departing executive's CV rather than the hotel's future requirements.
The result? A search that produces familiar candidates but potentially overlooks the person who could make the greatest difference.
The best candidate may come from an unexpected direction
Consider three examples.
The General Manager
A luxury resort wants to improve profitability while maintaining its reputation for exceptional service. The instinct may be to recruit another GM from a property of similar size and positioning.
But could a candidate who has led a successful operational improvement programme at a different type of luxury property bring something more valuable?
The Director of Finance
A hotel group is expanding across several destinations. Rather than automatically seeking someone with experience in the same brand, perhaps the priority should be multi-property financial leadership, systems implementation and the ability to support growth.
The Director of Sales and Marketing
A property is repositioning itself in a competitive luxury destination. The obvious candidate may have an impressive network and an established luxury brand pedigree. But a professional who has successfully built demand for a less established property might bring the more relevant experience.
In each case, the question is not whether the traditional candidate is suitable. It is whether the brief allows the best candidate to emerge.
This is where recruitment should begin
Before advertising a senior position or approaching the market, hotel owners, General Managers and HR Directors should consider four questions:
-
What must this person achieve in their first 12 months? Be specific about the commercial, operational or organisational outcomes required.
-
What capabilities are genuinely essential? Separate non-negotiable experience from preferences inherited from the previous jobholder.
-
What type of environment will this person inherit? Ownership style, team capability, brand structure and destination all influence the profile required.
-
Where else could the right experience be found? The best candidates may come from another brand, a different destination or an adjacent hospitality environment.
This does not mean lowering standards or ignoring relevant experience. It means defining those standards around the business challenge rather than an existing CV.
Why specialist executive search matters
A job description can describe a position. It cannot always explain the nuances that determine success in it.
Understanding those nuances requires conversations with the client, knowledge of hotel operations and an appreciation of what motivates experienced executives to move.
It also requires access to a wider talent market than the candidates who happen to be actively applying.
At Antal International – London Marylebone, we specialise in senior leadership recruitment for luxury and five-star hospitality across Italy, Europe, the Middle East and Asia.
Our approach is relationship-led and grounded in hospitality sector understanding. We work to understand the property, the ownership environment, the challenges ahead and the qualities that will make a candidate successful—not simply the experience listed on their CV.
Because sometimes the right appointment is not the person who most closely resembles the last executive.
It is the person who can take the hotel where it needs to go next.
A question for hotel owners and HR leaders
When you recruit a senior executive, do you start with the profile of the person who left—or with what the business needs to achieve next?
I'd be interested to hear how others approach this decision.